Topic: how to use multiple midi interfaces at once for recording?
- This topic has 8 replies, 7 voices, and was last updated 16 years ago by
druid.
-
March 11, 2010 at 10:49 #2163
abductedParticipanthello,
here is my problem:
I have a midi keyboard and a korg nanokontrol (this means 2 different midi inputs).
When I want to record notes, I have to chose the midi interface where the keyboard is plugged to (edirol usb soundcard midi in) and when I want to edit parameters of my vsti, I have to chose the nanokontrol midi interface.
This is very annoying.
I would like to use the 2 midi inputs at the same time, but it seems
that podium only allows to use one or the other?
Please help me understand this !March 11, 2010 at 12:59 #17668
MelodyManParticipantNo Windows-DAW can do what you want. It is a limitation of the ASIO-protocol. You can just record one device at a time. Apple has an aggregate driver, but Windows doesn’t (well, Direct Sound but the latency is high).
You could try ASIO4ALL. It is free and is a shell around the WDM-drivers. The performance for this isn’t bullet-proof though.
March 11, 2010 at 13:23 #17669
ZynewaveKeymaster@MelodyMan wrote:
No Windows-DAW can do what you want. It is a limitation of the ASIO-protocol. You can just record one device at a time. Apple has an aggregate driver, but Windows doesn’t (well, Direct Sound but the latency is high).
You could try ASIO4ALL. It is free and is a shell around the WDM-drivers. The performance for this isn’t bullet-proof though.
abducted is talking about MIDI inputs and not audio, so ASIO limitations is not an issue here.
March 11, 2010 at 13:32 #17670
ZynewaveKeymaster@abducted wrote:
hello,
here is my problem:
I have a midi keyboard and a korg nanokontrol (this means 2 different midi inputs).
When I want to record notes, I have to chose the midi interface where the keyboard is plugged to (edirol usb soundcard midi in) and when I want to edit parameters of my vsti, I have to chose the nanokontrol midi interface.
This is very annoying.
I would like to use the 2 midi inputs at the same time, but it seems
that podium only allows to use one or the other?
Please help me understand this !Good question. I’ve never had the need for multiple MIDI inputs on one track myself, but I can see that having this possibility would be useful.
Question to all:
How would you prefer this to work: Should it be possible to assign multiple inputs to one track? Should it be possible to set up more than one input with the “auto-assign to focus track” option? Should it be possible to configure a single MIDI input object to use more than one MIDI input interface (in the device mapping properties dialog)?
Anyone know how this is supported in other hosts?
March 11, 2010 at 15:00 #17671
kingtubbyParticipant@Zynewave wrote:
Anyone know how this is supported in other hosts?
Ableton Live allows you to select individual midi sources but also has an ‘all ins’ option. In FLstudio all midi sources are always available to which ever track is selected.
Mart.
March 11, 2010 at 18:10 #17672
LionParticipantMost programs just go with midi channels, and not a specific midi device.
There is a way you can do this with bomes midi translator, you need multiple instances of it tho for each device. Having each one output to the same midi yoke, then assign that midi yoke to the tracks device, and then it’ll simulate global devices.
Theres probably an easier way with a single program.
March 11, 2010 at 18:17 #17673
michi_makParticipantthis is easy : get MidiOX to merge all inputs and route them via MidiYoke into Podium – works well and i can’t find recognizable latency…
March 11, 2010 at 22:49 #17674
LionParticipant@michi_mak wrote:
this is easy : get MidiOX to merge all inputs and route them via MidiYoke into Podium – works well and i can’t find recognizable latency…
I forgot about MIDI-OX. You’re right, that should work. You’ll need to go to the same site for Midi Yoke anyway.
March 11, 2010 at 23:50 #17675
druidParticipantOn a similar topic, I used MIDI channels for a track so that within a VST (eneryXT) I could trigger other events with notes but not have them play back the synth inside. I found it useful, for instance, to switch between different filters for drum patterns (so, notes could tell it to switch between unfiltered, hipass or lopass filtering). By separating the channels, I could contain information in the one MIDI event that was meant to fit together, and not need automation just for switching an input between one or two others inside of energyXT.
I’m sure many people have more uses for MIDI channels than I did.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
